Saffery fined over serious Greensill audit failures

Saffery fined over serious Greensill audit failures

Saffery faces financial sanctions over serious failures auditing Greensill Capital. The FRC identified 23 admitted breaches involving risk assessment, audit evidence, and going concern, with further remedial measures required.


Accounting firm Saffery has been fined £581,250 over serious failures in its audit of Greensill Capital’s 2019 financial statements, following an investigation that identified 23 breaches of professional auditing requirements.

The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has also imposed a £124,000 financial sanction on Michael Di Leto, the audit engagement partner responsible for the work.

Both Saffery LLP and Di Leto received severe reprimands and orders requiring action to reduce the risk of similar breaches occurring again.

The investigation concerned the statutory audit of Greensill Capital (UK) Limited for the financial year ended 31 December 2019.

Greensill was the principal trading business of the wider Greensill Group, an Australian-headquartered financial services organisation specialising in working capital finance.

The business stopped originating new transactions on 2 March 2021 after experiencing difficulties renewing trade credit insurance. It entered administration on 8 March 2021, and the administration remains ongoing.

Saffery and Di Leto admitted 23 breaches involving the audit’s planning, risk assessment, accounting policies, revenue recognition, expected credit losses, and going concern assessment.

The FRC described the failures as serious and pervasive throughout the engagement.

The audit work did not adequately respond to significant risks that had been identified, including the possibility of material misstatements arising from revenue recognition, management overriding financial controls, and the valuation and recovery of assets.

The regulator also identified weaknesses in how audit evidence was reviewed, how quality control procedures operated, and the exercise of professional scepticism.

Auditors failed to assess significant risks —

A central finding concerned the auditors’ understanding of Greensill’s business model and the financial risks associated with its operations.

Working capital finance arrangements can involve complex relationships between customers, financing providers, receivables, and the parties ultimately responsible for payment.

Auditors examining such arrangements must understand how transactions are recorded, how assets are valued, and whether management’s assumptions are supported by appropriate evidence.

The FRC found that the audit team did not obtain a sufficient understanding of Greensill’s operations or consistently apply the scepticism necessary when assessing management’s information.

The investigation also identified failures concerning the company’s use of the going concern basis of accounting.

Going concern assessments examine whether an organisation can continue operating for the relevant reporting period. Directors are responsible for preparing those assessments, while auditors must evaluate the supporting evidence and the appropriateness of management’s conclusions.

The regulator found that Saffery’s work in this area was flawed despite the risks associated with Greensill’s business model.

However, the FRC explicitly stated that it was not suggesting the audit breaches caused Greensill Capital (UK) to enter administration.

The enforcement decision concerns failures to meet professional auditing requirements, rather than a finding that those failures were responsible for the company’s subsequent collapse.

The original financial sanctions were £750,000 for Saffery and £160,000 for Di Leto. Both were reduced by 22.5% in recognition of admissions and early resolution of the investigation.

The respondents must also pay the costs of the FRC’s investigation.

The regulator declared that the 2019 audit report signed on behalf of Saffery did not meet the relevant professional requirements.

Since the audit, Saffery has introduced changes to its audit processes and procedures, while Di Leto has undertaken remedial measures. Both cooperated with the investigation.

The FRC acknowledged those steps but said their effectiveness had not yet been assessed. The orders imposed as part of the sanctions will support further evaluation of the improvements and measures intended to prevent recurrence.

The case also reinforces the importance of auditors obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence when examining complex financing arrangements and management assessments that influence the reliability of corporate financial statements.

The final settlement concludes the FRC’s investigation into the 2019 audit, with the required remedial work remaining subject to regulatory oversight.

—



  • UK proposes new maritime fuel emissions rules

    UK proposes new maritime fuel emissions rules

    The UK is consulting on shipping fuel emissions intensity rules. Proposed requirements would initially cover larger vessels, domestic and international voyages, and operators’ transition to lower-emission energy.


  • Leeds Beckett opens digital innovation hub

    Leeds Beckett opens digital innovation hub

    Leeds Beckett has opened a new business digital innovation hub. The facility connects companies with AI expertise, cybersecurity support, specialist training, and collaborative technology projects.


  • Saffery fined over serious Greensill audit failures

    Saffery fined over serious Greensill audit failures

    Saffery faces financial sanctions over serious failures auditing Greensill Capital. The FRC identified 23 admitted breaches involving risk assessment, audit evidence, and going concern, with further remedial measures required.