Ofqual fines AQA over repeated braille failures

Ofqual fines AQA over repeated braille failures

Ofqual has fined AQA over serious repeated braille assessment errors. Investigators identified 56 accessibility problems in GCSE geography materials, alongside weaknesses in quality assurance, escalation procedures, and regulatory oversight.


Examination board AQA has been fined £350,000 following repeated failures in the production and quality assurance of braille assessment materials, including 56 accessibility errors identified in GCSE geography examinations and supporting resources.

The qualifications regulator Ofqual found weaknesses in AQA’s quality assurance, oversight, and risk management arrangements, alongside failures to investigate and escalate concerns that had first emerged during mock assessments in 2023.

The errors affected braille versions of GCSE geography assessment materials, including pre-release resources. Problems were identified in tactile maps, diagrams, graphs, and visual descriptions that students needed to understand and complete examination tasks.

Modified assessment materials are intended to allow students with particular accessibility requirements to demonstrate their knowledge and abilities on an equivalent basis to those using standard examination papers.

Preparing braille examinations can require substantial modification of conventional material. Maps and diagrams must be converted into formats that can be interpreted through touch, while written descriptions must communicate the information necessary to complete each question accurately.

Ofqual found that AQA had failed to identify and correct accessibility errors before materials were used in live examinations. Concerns about the quality of its GCSE geography braille assessments had already been raised following mock examinations in 2023.

However, opportunities to address those problems before the summer 2024 examination series were missed. AQA also failed to follow established escalation procedures, delaying the identification, investigation, and reporting of the full extent of the errors.

The regulator’s findings extended beyond the initial geography assessments. When determining the penalty, Ofqual considered further braille assessment errors identified across different regulated qualifications during 2024, 2025, and 2026.

Those incidents demonstrated that the problems were not confined to a single examination or production process. Ofqual concluded that they reflected broader deficiencies in the arrangements used to prepare, check, and oversee accessible assessment materials.

Examination boards operate under Ofqual’s General Conditions of Recognition, which require appropriate systems for maintaining the quality and validity of assessments, managing risks, and responding to events that could adversely affect learners.

These obligations extend to modified examination papers and supporting materials. Errors introduced during adaptation can affect students even where the corresponding standard assessment materials are accurate.

Ofqual’s wider monitoring of examination quality has identified recurring challenges involving accessible materials. Its 2025 delivery report recorded nine errors affecting only braille versions of assessment materials during that summer’s examinations, compared with 20 in 2024.

Eight of the nine errors identified in 2025 were discovered during or after the relevant examination. The regulator reported that affected questions were discounted or special consideration applied following assessment of the potential impact on students.

Those sector-wide figures are separate from the 56 errors identified in AQA’s GCSE geography materials and illustrate the wider work undertaken to monitor the accuracy of modified examinations.

Ofqual imposed the latest financial penalty on 2 November 2026 and published details of the enforcement action on 20 November. The sanction addresses multiple breaches of the General Conditions of Recognition.

AQA has accepted responsibility for the failings and agreed to pay the £350,000 fine, together with Ofqual’s reasonable legal costs. The organisation will also be required to implement a formal action plan addressing the weaknesses identified during the investigation.

The exam board introduced additional checks and strengthened oversight of its braille assessment materials ahead of the summer 2026 examinations. These changes form part of its response to concerns about the quality and accessibility of modified papers.

Ofqual will monitor the implementation and effectiveness of the formal action plan. It is also working with examination boards and the Joint Council for Qualifications to improve arrangements for producing accessible assessment materials and preventing errors.

The enforcement action establishes financial and operational consequences for AQA’s repeated failures, with further regulatory oversight focused on whether the organisation’s revised procedures provide effective quality assurance for braille assessments.

—



  • Ofqual fines AQA over repeated braille failures

    Ofqual fines AQA over repeated braille failures

    Ofqual has fined AQA over serious repeated braille assessment errors. Investigators identified 56 accessibility problems in GCSE geography materials, alongside weaknesses in quality assurance, escalation procedures, and regulatory oversight.


  • FRP Advisory expects 13% revenue growth

    FRP Advisory expects 13% revenue growth

    FRP Advisory expects higher revenue as corporate dealmaking activity strengthens. First-half sales are forecast to reach £98m, while underlying adjusted EBITDA is expected to grow 9% to £25m.


  • Fewer businesses report rising October turnover

    Fewer businesses report rising October turnover

    Fewer UK businesses reported rising turnover during October’s trading period. ONS survey figures show 14% experienced an increase, while 24% reported a decline, alongside continuing pressure from energy prices and economic uncertainty.