Workforce retraining programmes achieve better employment outcomes when employers contribute to their design and training is connected to specific occupations, according to a new government-commissioned evidence review.
The research, undertaken by the Institute for Employment Studies in partnership with the Learning and Work Institute, examines approaches used to help adults develop new skills and enter different jobs or sectors.
Published by the Department for Work and Pensions, the review identifies sustained employer engagement, occupation-specific training, participant assessment, and personalised support as recurring features of more effective programmes.
The findings are drawn from a rapid evidence assessment covering existing research and programme evaluations rather than a new national trial.
The authors found that training linked to particular occupations or industries was associated with more positive outcomes than generic provision.
Programmes with sustained employer participation also tended to perform better, particularly where businesses helped shape course content, provided information about local recruitment needs, and offered practical learning opportunities.
These relationships are important for local authorities and training providers deciding how to commission employment and skills programmes.
Courses developed without sufficient understanding of available jobs may leave participants with qualifications or skills that do not match the requirements of employers recruiting in the area.
By contrast, programmes designed with employers can reflect the technical skills, working conditions, and qualifications associated with particular occupations.
The research does not establish that employer engagement alone causes better employment outcomes. The authors found that successful programmes generally combined several features and that effectiveness varied with participants’ circumstances and local conditions.
Personalised support helps address participation barriers —
Alongside employer involvement, the review identifies personalised assistance as an important feature of programmes associated with better outcomes.
Participants may need help identifying suitable opportunities, assessing existing skills, developing confidence, and addressing practical obstacles before undertaking training.
These requirements differ considerably between someone changing occupation after redundancy and an individual returning to work after a prolonged period outside employment.
Appropriate screening and assessment before a programme begins can help establish whether the training matches an individual’s experience, capabilities, and employment objectives.
The review found some association between these arrangements and positive outcomes, although programme selection can also influence the characteristics of participants who complete training successfully.
Flexible delivery was another recurring feature, including arrangements that allow individuals to combine learning with employment, caring responsibilities, or other commitments.
However, the evidence suggested that flexibility primarily supported access and participation. It was not consistently associated with better employment or earnings outcomes in its own right.
Similar qualifications applied to financial assistance. Support with expenses can help individuals participate in training, but the available evidence did not establish that financial support independently improved longer-term employment outcomes.
Guaranteed interviews were also examined. The researchers considered them an indicator of employer involvement rather than a feature independently demonstrated to produce better results.
The evidence was less conclusive on how programmes should be structured and whether particular delivery organisations consistently performed better than others.
Comparisons between national, regional, and locally managed approaches were limited, while the available research provided insufficient evidence to establish value for money across different programme models.
These gaps are relevant as local and regional authorities take a greater role in coordinating employment support and skills provision.
The research forms part of the Labour Market Evidence Programme, commissioned to inform locally delivered support and the development of the What Works Centre for Local Employment Support.
Its conclusions favour programmes that combine employer engagement, training aligned with identifiable labour market demand, suitable participant assessment, and support tailored to individual circumstances.
However, the authors emphasise that effectiveness remains dependent on programme design, implementation, the population served, and local labour market conditions. The evidence does not support one universal delivery model for every area or group of participants.



